For several decades, events have led me to believe strongly in decentralization. Your brilliant essay has reassured me that I am not mistaken. Additionally, your suggestions for moving forward are the only viable solution. However, today, there is more money and power behind centralization than ever. I cannot see a path forward. We need thinkers like Julius Ruechel to be leaders in this world.
Very interesting. Many thanks for sharing. However, decentralized peer-to-peer electronic cash is only one small dimension of the decentralization that's needed.
Sure, peer-to-peer electronic cash is not everything. But money is currently very corrupted. Central banks and commercial banks create new money out of nothing. That gives them immense power, and they also act as gatekeepers between buyers and sellers in almost all transactions in highly digitised societies.
You are on target with the problem. Not sure of the solution, because any solution I can come with would be quickly weaponized, and create worse problems.
The issue is basic morality, which cannot be legislated. Moral behavior happens when you have transparency that comes from being known. When everyone knows me, and what I do, and there are consequences for my bad behavior then I am incentivized to behave well.
Decentralization I believe would work, and localism does work. (with freedom of movement, people would move the the most moral places encouraging moral behavoir on the part of elites) Unfortunately, we are going exactly the wrong way, and the only way I can see this happening is "Collapse", which would cause tremendous damage.....
I also struggle to see how we get back to decentralization without passing through a collapse phase because of how much resistance the necessary reforms would encounter from all those who benefit from the established order. For the time being, I am holding on to the hope that if we could just create one example, even on a small local scale to illustrate the principles, perhaps, perhaps, enough people would be inspired!
While there are many advantages to decentralization, does this not place a civilization at a great disadvantage against highly centralized states? For example, were China to engage in hostilities against the holy roman empire, the Chinese emperor would have a decisive advantage due to strategic coherence and mobilization, command and control, logistics, and finance...
Afghanistan showed a highly decentralized state can triumph, but they are a very peculiar mix of abject poverty, and drug money.
I fully agree with your point -- it truly is the main vulnerability. A great case in point is that Napoleon effectively collapsed the decentralized Holy Roman Empire when he began mobilizing his industrial scale French armies in pursuit of the conquest of Europe.
I fundamentally agree with the solutions you propose but suspect they will only be borne from collapse. Centralization is a consequence of the concentration of power and wealth. Corruption flows naturally from concentrating power. Those who enjoy this concentrated power and wealth will not give it up willingly. Fortunately we are traveling rapidly towards chaos and collapse. The US is already effectively bankrupt leaving the government with the only solution being to dramatically devalue the fiat dollar (significant purchasing power decline). If the federal government and its representatives had honored their oath to the US Constitution we would be in a far better place. The Constitution remains an extremely important tool to be used by the citizenry to drive us back to the decentralized world you envision. It is what they have been promised.
I really appreciated the history lesson you have offered here... it is truly enlightening with numerous corollaries to our present situation.
For several decades, events have led me to believe strongly in decentralization. Your brilliant essay has reassured me that I am not mistaken. Additionally, your suggestions for moving forward are the only viable solution. However, today, there is more money and power behind centralization than ever. I cannot see a path forward. We need thinkers like Julius Ruechel to be leaders in this world.
Decentralized peer-to-peer electronic cash could be a way forward.
I have written https://bitcoinsteffen.com/how-mastercard-and-bilderberg-group-have-sabotaged-bitcoin-btc/ which might include information which is news to you.
Very interesting. Many thanks for sharing. However, decentralized peer-to-peer electronic cash is only one small dimension of the decentralization that's needed.
Sure, peer-to-peer electronic cash is not everything. But money is currently very corrupted. Central banks and commercial banks create new money out of nothing. That gives them immense power, and they also act as gatekeepers between buyers and sellers in almost all transactions in highly digitised societies.
You are on target with the problem. Not sure of the solution, because any solution I can come with would be quickly weaponized, and create worse problems.
The issue is basic morality, which cannot be legislated. Moral behavior happens when you have transparency that comes from being known. When everyone knows me, and what I do, and there are consequences for my bad behavior then I am incentivized to behave well.
Decentralization I believe would work, and localism does work. (with freedom of movement, people would move the the most moral places encouraging moral behavoir on the part of elites) Unfortunately, we are going exactly the wrong way, and the only way I can see this happening is "Collapse", which would cause tremendous damage.....
I also struggle to see how we get back to decentralization without passing through a collapse phase because of how much resistance the necessary reforms would encounter from all those who benefit from the established order. For the time being, I am holding on to the hope that if we could just create one example, even on a small local scale to illustrate the principles, perhaps, perhaps, enough people would be inspired!
Decentralized peer-to-peer electronic cash could be a way forward.
I have written https://bitcoinsteffen.com/how-mastercard-and-bilderberg-group-have-sabotaged-bitcoin-btc/ which might include information which is news to you.
While there are many advantages to decentralization, does this not place a civilization at a great disadvantage against highly centralized states? For example, were China to engage in hostilities against the holy roman empire, the Chinese emperor would have a decisive advantage due to strategic coherence and mobilization, command and control, logistics, and finance...
Afghanistan showed a highly decentralized state can triumph, but they are a very peculiar mix of abject poverty, and drug money.
I fully agree with your point -- it truly is the main vulnerability. A great case in point is that Napoleon effectively collapsed the decentralized Holy Roman Empire when he began mobilizing his industrial scale French armies in pursuit of the conquest of Europe.
Another gem, thank you. Our political "leaders" would do well to subscribe :-)
🙏
I fundamentally agree with the solutions you propose but suspect they will only be borne from collapse. Centralization is a consequence of the concentration of power and wealth. Corruption flows naturally from concentrating power. Those who enjoy this concentrated power and wealth will not give it up willingly. Fortunately we are traveling rapidly towards chaos and collapse. The US is already effectively bankrupt leaving the government with the only solution being to dramatically devalue the fiat dollar (significant purchasing power decline). If the federal government and its representatives had honored their oath to the US Constitution we would be in a far better place. The Constitution remains an extremely important tool to be used by the citizenry to drive us back to the decentralized world you envision. It is what they have been promised.
I really appreciated the history lesson you have offered here... it is truly enlightening with numerous corollaries to our present situation.